AB Pol Econ

Is Danielle Smith a Separatist/Annexationist? Part 5- Alberta Next

19Jul

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Intergovernmental, Opinion/Research, Politics, Rural

Is Danielle Smith a Separatist/Annexationist? Part 5- Alberta Next

Note to readers: The comments section below is now functioning. Please feel free to comment on any of my scribbling. I would like to hear what you think. Key takeaways Constitutional reforms and fiscal reform proposals likely a non-starter Expect the UCP to move forward on an Alberta police force irrespective of what Albertans and rural Councillors think. Expect Smith to move on restricting social services to immigrants Tax collection and the Alberta Pension Plan actions will depend on next year's referendum results. Quite a lot has happened in Alberta politics since my last blog which covered Smith’s post-federal election speech (25 May 2025). Intervening events have included the 23 May by-elections which drew low voter turnouts while maintaining the current seat standi...

Elizabeth Smythe- Democracy in Alberta – Interview

1Jun

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Energy, Politics

Elizabeth Smythe- Democracy in Alberta – Interview

For the video, click here. In this episode, Dr. Elizabeth Smythe speaks about her course on democracy at Edmonton Lifelong Learners' Association (ELLA) this past May. She discusses western political scientists' views on democracy, including ideas about "exporting" democracy. She explains the evolution of government authority from absolute monarchy to today's representative system as well as direct democracy. Representative democracies are not purely democratic, however because voter franchises expanded only after significant push by those representing under-represented groups like women or men without property. In addressing democracy in Alberta, she notes a decided trend toward the cabinet (executive) making decisions rather than representative elected bodies. Democratic b...

Is Smith really a separatist/annexationist? Part 4- ‘My fellow Albertans’

25May

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Credit Ratings, Energy, Environment, Government Finances, Intergovernmental, Investment, Politics

Is Smith really a separatist/annexationist? Part 4- ‘My fellow Albertans’

“Separation, if necessary, but not necessarily separation” Introduction Premier Danielle Smith’s 5 May 2025 address followed by one week the Liberals’ near-majority re-election. Smith chose to deliver Her update on the ongoing war with “Ottawa.” “Ottawa” is code for the federal Liberal Party elite and is frequently used word to disparage the federal government. Smith used Ottawa 15 times in this address. Smith, ever the articulate, telegenic leader is a consummate communicator who has learned on the radio talk circuit as well during Her political career, didn't disappoint. She comes across as a voice of reason and the mainstream listener may not fully understand the underlying coded messages. In this analysis, I examine the text of Her address as well as watching/listening to...

Is Danielle Smith really a separatist/annexationist? Part 3- Survey results

17May

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Credit Ratings, Energy, Government Finances, Investment, Opinion/Research, Politics

Is Danielle Smith really a separatist/annexationist? Part 3- Survey results

Note to readers: The comments section below is now functioning. Please feel free to comment on any of my scribbling. I would like to hear what you think. In this part I examine recent and some historical polling data on Alberta separatism. In subsequent parts I will review Premier Smith’s “address” to Albertans and her salvo of fury over Mark Carney’s cabinet choices. Smith has clearly gone on the offensive since revelations in early February about suspicious procurement practices at Alberta Health Services surfaced. As a former colleague of mine at ATB used to characterize changing the narrative, Smith and her communications staff have embarked on a massive “head fake.” Recent polling by the Angus Reid Institute show that 48 per cent or roughly half of a randomized sample of...

Is Danielle Smith really a Separatist/Annexationist? Part 2

4May

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Credit Ratings, Economic Data, Energy, Government Finances, Intergovernmental, Opinion/Research

Is Danielle Smith really a Separatist/Annexationist? Part 2

Updated 3 May 2025 Note to readers: The comments section below is now functioning. Please feel free to comment on any of my scribbling. I would like to hear what you think. Explanatory comment I have been working on this question for the better part of three weeks spurred on my the concatenation of Her fiery speech to the Legislative Assembly on 26 March, Her attacks on Carney and the trip to PungurU and Ben Shapiro, revealed She was exploring the idea of independence ("from Ottawa) or statehood ("Texas of the North). As this blogs shows it is charitable to say Smith is "flirting" with separatism. It's doubtful there was that much open animosity between Ottawa and Quebec during 2 referenda. Smith's fiery speech might be compared to pre-Civil War missives from the south to Washingto...

Is Danielle Smith really a Separatist or Annexationist? Part 1

30Apr

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Credit Ratings, Economic Data, Energy, Government Finances, Intergovernmental, Opinion/Research

Is Danielle Smith really a Separatist or Annexationist? Part 1

Note to readers: The comments section below is now functioning. Please feel free to comment on any of my scribbling. I would like to hear what you think. Background In a June 2023 article in The Conversation I raised the question “Will Danielle Smith veer back to the right and towards Alberta separatism?” At the time, a month after Smith’s United Conservative Party won the general election, I argued that Alberta had an economic and financial “ace in the hole”- Alberta’s vast export surplus driven by conventional and unconventional oil. Alberta separation would mean that Canadians' standard of living would drop significantly as would the Canadian dollar. I also noted that, unlike Quebec Inc., the ownership of Alberta’s fossil fuel-based economy is largely controlled by American financia...

27Apr

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Banks, Energy, Environment, Investment, Opinion/Research, Politics

Presentation to Philosophers’ Cafe- Mark Carney’s book Value(s)

Updated 1 May 2025. On Saturday 26 April, I was invited to present to the Philosophers' Cafe on Mark Carney's 2021 book Value(s). It was a pleasure to present this to an exceptional group of engaged, mostly seniors. This invitation from Professor Emeritus Martin Tweedle was prompted by a book review I can written in May 2021 on Carney's "Magnum Opus." You can access my dressed up speaking notes in the PDF file below. The discussion was spirited at times with many questions coming back to who is this man? Can he be trusted given his corporate connections? Unlike the book review, my presentation made some additional points about the book. First, Carney left the Bank of England (BoE) at the end of February 2020 and yet he had the final 600 -page manuscript to the publi...

2Apr

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Agencies, Government Finances, Health, Opinion/Research, Politics

Chronology of Events- AHS CEO’s Statement of Claim

This detailed chronology is drawn from the statement of claim by Athana Mentzelopoulos (SOC), statements of defence (SOD) from the Government of Alberta /Adriana LaGrange (GOA) and by Alberta Health Services (AHS) and Mentzelopoulos's reply to the statements of defence (REP). The chronology should be read in conjunction with Smith, LaGrange, Alberta public service face grave test and Mentzelopoulos: AHS, Government defence and plaintiff's reply. This litigation is extraordinarily complex and allegations have not been proven in court. Perceptions differ among the participants and what one says versus what is heard to said may be completely different. The Government and AHS's narrative focuses on Mentzelopoulos's failure to lead the reorganization of AHS into Acute Care Alberta. It also r...

Mentzelopoulos: AHS, Government defence and plaintiff’s reply

2Apr

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Agencies, Budget, Health, Opinion/Research, Politics

Mentzelopoulos: AHS, Government defence and plaintiff’s reply

Note: this post should be read in conjunction with "Smith, LaGrange, Alberta public service face grave test" which examined the Statement of Claim brought by the former President and CEO of Alberta Health Services, Athana Mentzelopoulos against AHS, Adriana LaGrange and the Government of Alberta. In addition a Chronology of Events provides a detailed timeline based on the statements filed at the Court of King's Bench. No allegations have been proven in Court. The full Statement of Claim (SOC) is found below. Government of Alberta (GOA), Adriana LaGrange Statement of Defence (filed 18 March) The statement of defence (SOD) may be found below. Health Minister LaGrange and the Government of Alberta are represented by Bennett Jones LLP (Munaf Mohamed KC). The GOA defence r...

23Mar

By Bob AscahNo Comments

Energy, Environment, Intergovernmental, Opinion/Research

Premier Smith threatens national unity crisis- it’s about distraction

Note to readers: The comments section below is now functioning. Please feel free to comment on any of my scribbling. I would like to hear what you think. It has been a busy week since Mark Carney was elected Liberal Party leader and formed a government. Danielle Smith has used Carney’s recent and rapid rise as Liberal leader to set out conditions (see below) for either the new Liberal PM or a future CPC leader, Pierre Poilievre to meet. All of these demands are rooted in the goals of the oil and gas industry or the Take-Back-Alberta activists now controlling the United Conservative Party. Last week I canvassed Smith’s fusillade at newly sworn in PM Carney of 14 March. This past week she has continued her campaign to force federal political leaders to come on board to in effect ...